Tokens or unlimited subscription: which model should you pick for an AI companion?

Two apps at $12/month can have real prices three times apart. The difference doesn’t show on the pricing page: it’s hidden in the billing model, tokens or unlimited.

Here’s how to spot which one you’re buying, and how to calculate what you’ll actually pay.

Try SpicyChat AI for free

The two models, one sentence each

Unlimited subscription: a flat price, no usage meter. You pay the same whether you send 10 messages or 500.

Token-based: every action has a cost (image, video, voice call, sometimes even the message itself), drawn from a balance that refills monthly or gets topped up separately. The subscription often only covers text, everything else drains the meter.

Most apps in this category aren’t purely one or the other: they mix unlimited text with token-based media. That hybrid setup is what trips up the most people, because the advertised price only talks about the unlimited part.

The calculation that changes everything: the real cost of an action

On token-based apps, the price that matters is never the subscription, it’s the unit cost of what you actually use.

JOI AI is the clearest example. A video call costs 2,000 Neurons per 5 minutes. The free starting balance (10 Neurons, up to 200 with referrals) doesn’t even cover a minute of calling. A handful of calls empty an entire monthly subscription.

FantasyGF runs the same mechanic on a 100-token monthly allowance: an image costs 7 tokens, a minute of voice call 30 tokens. A hundred tokens is about three minutes of voice calling for the whole month. Token top-ups, not the subscription, are the real business model.

Promptchan counts in Gems: roughly 2 Gems per image, 18 per video, 1 for a voice message. A hundred Gems included in the Plus tier barely covers fifty simple images or five videos. The subscription doesn’t make everything unlimited, only the most basic generations on the priciest tier are.

OurDream AI adds a variable nobody advertises: a video generation failure rate of around 40%. A failed attempt still consumes your tokens. The real cost per successful video is nearly double the advertised price.

Where the unlimited subscription actually delivers

SpicyChat has the most honest offer in the ranking on this point: text messages are genuinely unlimited, for free, without the usual 50 or 100 a day. The tradeoffs sit elsewhere (peak-hour queues, ads), not in a hidden meter.

Kindroid bundles selfies, voice calls, and short videos into a single subscription, with no separate currency to top up. The tradeoff isn’t price, it’s speed: up to 7 minutes to generate a single image.

Candy.ai covers text as unlimited within the subscription, but switches to tokens the moment media is involved. It’s an openly hybrid model, and a good chunk of user complaints comes from people who didn’t anticipate that rule change mid-conversation.

Two billing tricks worth knowing

The weekly rate disguised as a modest one. Kupid AI charges $12.99 per week. That looks harmless next to a $12.99 monthly subscription, but it adds up to roughly $675 a year, almost four times the price of a comparable annual plan.

The countdown that never counts down. Nemora permanently displays an “up to 80% off” banner with a timer frozen at zero. The discount never expires: it’s not urgency, it’s staging. No time-limited promotion in this category should ever rush a decision.

The method for calculating the real price before you pay

Three steps, before you pull out your card:

1. Find out what’s genuinely unlimited in the subscription. Often just text. Check whether image, voice, or video are included or draw from a separate balance.
2. Find the unit cost of the action you’ll do most. Price of an image, a minute of calling, a video. It’s almost always written in small print, far from the subscription price featured up front.
3. Multiply by your real weekly usage, not an optimistic monthly one. A 10-minute video call a day on JOI AI, for instance, blows past any regular monthly subscription.

If step 2 is hard to find on the site, that’s information in itself: an app that hides its unit cost is probably counting on you not doing the math.

Which app to pick based on your usage

You mostly chat in text, without heavy image or video use: an unlimited subscription like SpicyChat or Kindroid costs less and avoids any nasty surprise.

You want lots of images or videos regularly: calculate the unit cost before choosing between Promptchan, FantasyGF, or JOI AI. The priciest tier isn’t always the best value if basic generations cover your usage.

You want to test before committing: always start with the free tier or a single month, never an annual plan. Annual billing does save 30 to 50% on most apps, but only if you’re still using the service by month four, which most people aren’t.

Bottom line

An unlimited subscription protects you from having to do math, a token model shifts the real price toward your actual usage. Neither is bad on its own: the problem is choosing without doing the calculation. Before paying, find the unit cost of what you’ll do most, multiply by a realistic week, and compare that number to the advertised subscription rather than its sticker price.